From: David Bostwick <bostwick@cas.chemistry.gatech.edu>
Subject: RESULT: comp.object.moderated moderated passes 324:24
Date: 1998/11/19
Date: 1998-11-19T00:00:00+00:00 [thread overview]
Message-ID: <911496584.20382@isc.org> (raw)
In-Reply-To: 910744959.17155@isc.org
[-- Warning: decoded text below may be mangled, UTF-8 assumed --]
[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 39774 bytes --]
RESULT
moderated group comp.object.moderated passes 324:24
There were 324 YES votes and 24 NO votes, for a total of 348 valid votes.
There were 5 abstains.
For group passage, YES votes must be at least 2/3 of all valid (YES and NO)
votes. There also must be at least 100 more YES votes than NO votes.
There is a five day discussion period after these results are posted. If no
serious allegations of voting irregularities are raised, the moderator of
news.announce.newgroups will create the group shortly thereafter.
Newsgroups line:
comp.object.moderated A moderated forum for Object-oriented issues. (Moderated)
The voting period ended at 23:59:59 UTC, 18 Nov 1998.
This vote was conducted by a neutral third party. Questions
about the proposed group should be directed to the proponent.
Proponent: Tim Ottinger <ottinger@oma.com>
Votetaker: David Bostwick <bostwick@cas.chemistry.gatech.edu>
RATIONALE: comp.object.moderated
Object-oriented programming has long ago graduated from a niche study
to an industry force, so the discussion of things object-oriented has
likewise increased in general interest and audience. This surge has
increased the participation in comp.object so that it is difficult for
participants to keep up with the volume.
In addition, the comp.object newsgroup now receives a substantial
number of inappropriate posts, much of which are of little value or
interest to the community at large, and a large number of which are
easily characterized as "flames" or "trolls".
For those who would like to have a greater signal-to-noise ratio
than is afforded in comp.object, we wish to create a second,
separate newsgroup which is moderated to reduce the occurrance
of spam, flames, trolls, and off-topic posts. In this way, the
newsgroup will cater to professionals with less time for scanning the
news, and those who wish to avoid flames.
The moderators of comp.object.moderated were elected by a
public, majority vote on comp.object and have produced a
policy which they feel will encourage OO discussions and
attract new readers and expert participants.
Comp.object will not be moderated, though. It will remain as an
alternative. On comp.object, one may have discussions on more
tangential topics. Comp.object.moderated merely provides the
readership with a well-focused, flame-free, spam-free choice.
CHARTER: comp.object.moderated
Comp.object.moderated is a moderated news group for discussion of
issues directly related to Object-oriented theory and Object-oriented
practice, and of general interest to the Object-oriented community.
Any such articles are welcome, and are recommendations of alternative
approaches in response to questions directly related to
Object-oriented theory or practice.
Moderation Policy:
I PRINCIPLES
Moderation is desired to attract and maintain participation by old
posters, new posters, and especially expert posters. To do so,
comp.object.moderated provides a non-threatening forum for discussing
Object-oriented practice and theory. To attract and maintain a large
professional readership this policy ensures that the forum is as
concise and useful as it can possibly be.
Here is what this moderation policy is intended to achieve with
respect to each article:
1) ON TOPIC
2) NO FLAMES
3) NO SPAM
4) NO NONSENSE
These goals are characterized as follows:
1) ON TOPIC
(Discussions of) the following subjects are regarded as being on topic
in comp.object.moderated:
a) the syntax and semantics of various Object-oriented languages, b)
Object-oriented tricks and techniques, c) case studies, d) issues of
software engineering related to Object-oriented, e) issues of software
management related to Object-oriented, f) issue of design philosophy
related to Object-oriented, g) design patterns related to
Object-oriented, etc. h) Object-oriented analysis techniques. i)
Object-oriented process. j) Object-oriented tools. k) Object-oriented
Modeling. l) any and all other discussions relating or pertaining to
Object- oriented techniques. m) management and policy of the
newsgroup.
Articles may be rejected as being off-topic if there are
other, more specific newsgroups to which they belong.
If an article references products like tools, libraries or
platforms, it is still acceptable if the article just mentions
these products as illustrations or examples and abstains from
support questions.
When in doubt:
An article shall be accepted, especially for short off-topic
digressions in a thread. In order to keep the noise level low, if such
an article has already been accepted in recent days, the moderator
body may decide to reject the newer one and refer the author to the
earlier one.
2) NO FLAMES
a) No threats or attempts at intimidation are tolerated. Those drive
away audience. New posters are intimidated by it, and experts don't
have the time or energy to waste on it. Such things are personal, and
not of interest to the general Object-oriented audience.
b) No disrespect towards others is tolerated. When people are unkind,
new people will choose not to participate. Personal feelings against
one or another are not of interest to the general Object-oriented
audience. People should read all ideas, and choose the ones that work
for them, and a poor idea should be shown to be poor by technical or
practical reasons.
c) No disdainful or belittling articles are tolerated, no matter
whether the contents of the article are otherwise correct or not.
d) Questioning of other people's motives and honesty is explicitly
considered both off-topic and extremely rude, no matter whether the
contents of the article are otherwise correct or not.
d) Any but the most light-hearted attempts at one-upmanship will be
disallowed. Participation in a comp.object.moderated thread is not a
contest with prizes for the winners.
In essence, all attempts to hijack comp.object.moderated to wage a
personal attack would not only be counter-productive, but also
off-topic. When people speak against each other, they've lost focus on
the issues at hand.
When in doubt:
An article is rejected. Not a flame shall pass through.
3) NO NONSENSE
a) FAQs aren't nonsense, but the repeated posting and answering of
them is. Nobody wants to read the exact same questions and answers
over and over. It's a burden on the reader that gates his productive
use of the forum.
b) Verbatim or slightly rephrased reposts are nonsense.
c) Trolls are nonsense.
d) Binaries are considered inappropriate in this newsgroup.
In short, comp.object.moderated should be a forum you can read with
the same confidence you have reading a manual or technical journal. It
is an interactive professional forum, not a hobbyist board or a war
board. It belongs to the community of people whose work is the
practice and theory of Object-Orientation, and anything that turns the
newsgroup away from that community, or turns the community away from
the newsgroup, is not welcome.
When in doubt:
An article is accepted, general noise level permitting.
4) NO SPAM
The war on SPAM is the war to maintain control of the professional
nature and the signal-to-noise ratio of a newsgroup.
The Jargon File (http://sagan.earthspace.net/jargon) describes
spam in the following terms:
"...To cause a newsgroup to be flooded with irrelevant or
inappropriate messages. [...] To send many identical
or nearly-identical messages separately to a large number
of Usenet newsgroups..."
Whatever a moderator has to do to stop SPAM without rejecting
legitimate posts is good. If stopping spam means blacklisting
spam-posters, then so be it. If it involves building complex filtering
rules, fine. If it is easily handled by rejecting posts, fine again.
When in doubt:
An article is rejected.
II MEANS
These goals are to be achieved as follows:
1) Automated format checking
If the posted article is not properly formatted (i.e. the news headers
aren't right -- your news software should take care of this) or if the
article is larger than 50KB, then it will be automatically rejected.
The poster may or may not be notified of this kind of rejection,
depending upon just how bad the headers were. Articles without Date:
or Subject: headers are not properly formatted.
2) Moderator Notes
Moderators may add a note to an article only for the reasons and
according to the policies stated above, to correct incomplete or
incorrect references, or to recommend changing thread titles when
topics drift from their original focus.
The form of those notes will always be the same. They will composed of
text in square brackets. The last four characters of the text in
square brackets will be -mod. Thus:
[text of the note. -mod].
Moderators will be extremely conservative with their use of notes.
Most articles should not have any notes. Those that do should have
only one, or at the most two. So be judicious.
3) Acceptance and Rejection Procedures
Accepted articles are to be posted immediately. When an article is
rejected by a moderator, it will be emailed back to the poster. The
subject of the email message will be: "Rejected, violates: [reason
list]." where reason list is a comma separated list of the codes
specified in the acceptance criteria above. e.g. "Rejected, violates:
[ON TOPIC, NO FLAMES c)]."
The moderator should include moderator notes in the body of the
article that explain why the article was rejected. The format of those
notes should be as specified above, but they can be as brief or wordy
as needed to get the point across. There also may be as many as
needed.
4) Moderator Anonymity
Moderators act as a single body. Any rejection should be viewed as a
rejection by the moderators and not by any particular moderator. As
such, the identity of the rejecting moderator will not be exposed to
the poster whose article was rejected (i.e. the moderator's signature
will be stripped). Any questions that the poster may have can be
referred to the moderator's hotline email address.
5) Appeal Policy
Any poster of a rejected message may appeal that rejection to the
moderators by emailing the article to the moderators' hotline. The
moderators will review the rejection and either post or reject the
article based upon their conclusion.
6) Moderator Posting Policy
Moderators are not allowed to moderate their own articles. No article
written by a moderator will be posted unless one of the other
moderators accepts it.
7) Moderator Body
The number of moderators shall not become less than five, so as to
preserve the integrity of the appeal process.
When there is a shortage of moderators, the remaining moderators
select willing volunteers who are participants in the newsgroup and
whose posting history shows understanding of and respect for the
moderation policy.
H) FAQ
There will be a collection of answers to comp.object.moderated FAQs
which is made publicly and freely available. The moderator body
maintains, extends and publishes this FAQ document and points the
comp.object.moderated readers to it as appropriate. The moderator body
may decide to delegate this work.
END CHARTER.
MODERATOR INFO: comp.object.moderated
Moderator: Patrick Logan <plogan@teleport.com>
Moderator: Patrick Doyle <doylep@ecf.utoronto.ca>
Moderator: Martijn Meijering <mmeijeri@wi.leidenuniv.nl>
Moderator: John Goodsen <jgoodsen@saguarosoft.com>
Moderator: Rolf Katzenberger <rfkat@ibm.net>
Moderator: Yonat Sharon <yonat@usa.net>
Administrative contact address: comp.object.maintainer@oma.com
Article submission address: com.submit@oma.com
END MODERATOR INFO.
comp.object.moderated Final Vote Ack
Voted Yes
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1grotria [at] informatik.uni-hamburg.de Peter Grotrian
70672.1744 [at] compuserve.com John I. Moore, Jr.
aaw [at] ascham.demon.co.uk Anthony Willoughby
adam [at] flash.irvine.com Adam Beneschan
adrianh [at] victoriareal.co.uk Adrian Howard
ady [at] thermoteknix.co.uk Ady Coles
afrazer [at] ophelia.telstra.com.au Andrew Frazer
ahecht [at] mindspring.com Alan Hecht
alfred.gebert [at] systor.com Alfred Gebert
allender [at] erols.com John Allender
andy [at] ffaltd.demon.co.uk Andy Hunt
anilk [at] arbornet.org Anil Krishnamurthy
anupriyo [at] delphi.com Anupriyo Chakravarti
arielle [at] taronga.com Stephanie da Silva
ark [at] research.att.com Andrew Koenig
assfalg [at] dsi.unifi.it Jurgen Assfalg
a_bond [at] rinet.ru Anton Bondarenko
BAILEYK [at] SCHNEIDER.COM Kendall Bailey
balser [at] uke.uni-hamburg.de Markus Balser
barry.prescott [at] wanadoo.fr Barry Prescott
bbutton [at] insight-tech.com Brian Button
BCasiello [at] Banyan.com Brian Casiello
behrends [at] cse.msu.edu Reimer Behrends
bernhard.buergin [at] ubs.com Bernard Burgin
bert [at] dgb.nl Bert Bril
bijuthom [at] ibm.net Biju Thomas
bill [at] wadley.org Bill Wadley
binkley [at] bigfoot.com Brian Keith Oxley
bjv [at] herbison.com B.J. Herbison
bmiller [at] cccglobal.com Brian R. Miller
bodewig [at] bost.de Stefan Bodewig
booda [at] datasync.com Martin H. Booda
boud [at] rempt.xs4all.nl Boudewijn Rempt
bparsia [at] email.unc.edu Bijan Parsia
bpr [at] best.com Brian Rogoff
bradapp [at] enteract.com Brad Appleton
brand [at] nina.pagesz.net Jeff Brandenburg
Brane.Dernac [at] select-tech.si Brane Dernac
brangdon [at] cix.co.uk Dave Harris
britt [at] acm.org F. BRITT SNODGRASS
BrookeF [at] gvsi.com Brooke Fair
Brownsta [at] concentric.net Stan Brown
bsey [at] pobox.com Bill Seymour
burris [at] neosoft.com Rick A. Burris
c [at] nautronix.com.au carl johnson
c.stadler [at] delta-ii.de Christof Stadler
Caedmontwo [at] aol.com Troy Caedmon Parsons
cameron-mellor [at] deshaw.com Cameron Mellor
cd [at] tps.de Charles Dapp
Charles.Burton [at] evolving.com Chuck Burton
chrismck [at] earthlink.net Christine McKenna
Christian.Angerer [at] sea.ericsson.se Christian Angerer
christopher.varlese [at] broadnet.ascom.ch Christopher Varlese
ckf [at] majure.com Creighton K. Frommer
clayberg [at] smalltalksystems.com Eric Clayberg
coelho [at] dca.fee.unicamp.br Andre Luis Vasconcelos Coelho
craig [at] scot.demon.co.uk Craig Cockburn
crawley [at] dstc.edu.au Stephen Crawley
crocker [at] cig.mot.com Ron Crocker
CVilla [at] tekscan.com Charles W. Villa
czerwonka [at] corbatech.com Andy L. Czerwonka
dacut [at] ece.cmu.edu David A. Cuthbert
daniel.sundman [at] usa.net Daniel Sundman
danielp [at] interlog.com Daniel Parker
Danny.Lingman.lingman [at] nt.com Dan Lingman
dany.steyaert [at] ping.be Dany Steyaert
DasBuro.Com!mfx [at] DasBuro.com Markus Freericks
dave [at] goopot.demon.co.uk David Potts
Dave.Murrells [at] ehv.ce.philips.com David Murrells
davep [at] iisc.co.uk Dave Postill
daver [at] teleport.com D Reynolds
david [at] elqui.qant.ucl.ac.be David Massart
david [at] farrar.com David Farrar
david [at] pottage.demon.co.uk David Pottage <david [at] pottage.demon.co.u
david.price [at] research.nokia.com David Price
david.whipp [at] hl.siemens.de David Whipp
David_Keller [at] sealand.com David A. Keller
dbh [at] transarc.com David Hodge
dboucher [at] locus.ca Dominique Boucher
dc [at] panix.com David W. Crawford
dermot [at] clubi.ie Dermot Casey
DESiegel [at] aol.com D. E. Siegel
dittmann [at] gfai.de Stephan Dittmann
dittoC [at] ix.netcom.com David Cattarin
dkarr [at] nmo.gtegsc.com David M. Karr
dlmatt [at] canopus.bu.edu Dr. David L. Matthews
Dmckeon [at] swcp.com Denis McKeon
Dominique.Colnet [at] loria.fr Dominique Colnet
doylep [at] ecf.utoronto.ca Patrick Doyle
dpw [at] cs.arizona.edu Don Waugaman
DRaizen [at] dataware.com Dan Raizen
drybowski [at] email.com Daniel Rybowski
dsr [at] mail.lns.cornell.edu Dan Riley
duncan [at] esatst.yc.estec.esa.nl Duncan Gibson
e.blood [at] citr.com Eric Blood
ehoffman [at] fzi.de Ekkehard Hoffmann
ehsmalu [at] ehpt.com Mattias Lundstrom
Ekkehard.Uthke [at] gmx.de Ekkehard Uthke
ems [at] jrandom.com Erik Seaberg
eric [at] aerie-pr.com Eric G. Roesinger
eric.diamond [at] bankerstrust.com Eric Diamond
eridani [at] databasix.com Belinda
esap [at] cs.tut.fi Esa Pulkkinen
escowles [at] gort.ucsd.edu Esme Cowles
ewan_benson [at] hotmail.com Ewan Benson
e_j_m [at] yahoo.com Eric Miller
FALE [at] skidata.com Leopold Faschalek
falk.bruegmann [at] student.uni-augsburg.de Falk Bruegmann
fche [at] cygnus.com Frank Ch. Eigler
fischerd [at] rd.hydro.on.ca Daniel Fischer
fjh [at] cs.mu.OZ.AU Fergus Henderson
Frank_Adrian [at] firstdatabank.com Frank A. Adrian
franz [at] mips.complang.tuwien.ac.at Franz Puntigam
Franz.Seiser [at] sea.ericsson.se Franz Seiser
fredrik [at] pythonware.com Fredrik Lundh
f_clerc [at] effix.fr Fabrice Clerc
g.h.smith [at] marconicomms.com Graham Smith
gavan [at] magna.com.au Gavan Schneider
gboes [at] ashfordtech.com Greg Boes
gdosreis [at] sophia.inria.fr Gabriel Dos Reis
gelderen [at] mediaport.org Jeroen C. van Gelderen
geneo [at] Rational.Com Gene Ouye
Geoff_Odhner [at] franklin.com Geoffrey Odhner
gerald.zottl [at] sea.ericsson.se Gerald Zottl
gerhard.menzl [at] sea.ericsson.se Gerhard Menzl
graham [at] parana.pentacom.co.uk Graham Ward
gregfra [at] iname.com Greg Franklin
gregm_spam_bites [at] cc.gatech.edu Greg Montgomery
grenning [at] oma.com James W. Grenning
gsez020 [at] compo.bedford.waii.com Pete Forman
guymacon [at] deltanet.com guymacon [at] deltanet.com (Guy Macon)
harry.protoolis [at] nautronix.com.au Harry Protoolis
harvey [at] iupui.edu James Harvey
heiler [at] rumms.uni-mannheim.de Matthias Heiler
holger [at] wizards.de Holger Hoffstaette
hslama [at] datacomm.ch Heribert Slama
hubert [at] patrol.i-way.co.uk Hubert Matthews
hymie [at] prolifics.com Hyman Rosen
hyphen [at] xs4all.nl Carlo Hogeveen
ica2ph [at] csv.ica.uni-stuttgart.de Peter Hermann
James.Bridson [at] ks.sel.alcatel.de James M. Bridson
James.Weirich [at] sdrc.com Jim Weirich
jamesr [at] objectshare.com James A. Robertson
james_wolffe [at] ny.essd.northgrum.com James Wolffe
jap [at] interaccess.com Jeff Pleimling
jb [at] mail.com John Burton
jcoffin [at] taeus.com Jerry Coffin
jdassen [at] wi.leidenuniv.nl J.H.M. Dassen
jeff [at] mdli.com Jeff Younker
jgoodsen [at] radsoft.com John Goodsen
jharby [at] san.rr.com John Harby
jhg [at] acm.org James Garrison
jim.ancona [at] geac.com Jim Ancona
jkr [at] phon1.ikp.uni-bonn.de Juergen Kraemer
joachim.durchholz [at] munich.netsurf.de Joachim Durchholz
joet [at] cse.unsw.edu.au Joe Thurbon
johanj [at] acm.org Johan Johansson
jonboy [at] onlink.net Trevor Tymchuk
JonesR [at] tetraworld.com Rick Jones
josef.fromwald [at] sea.ericsson.se Josef Fromwald
jpotter [at] falcon.lhup.edu John Potter
jsiegle [at] phoenix.lhup.edu Jonathan Siegle
julesd [at] erols.com Jules Dubois
junga [at] leo.org Achim Jung
juris [at] rfb.lv Juris Krikis
K.Hagan [at] thermoteknix.co.uk Ken Hagan
kapson [at] mays.Central.Sun.COM John Kapson
kderrick [at] my-dejanews.com Keith Derrick
keegansj [at] perkin-elmer.com Stephen Keegan
keesey [at] us.ibm.com James Keesey
kelley [at] ruralnet.net Kevin Kelley
Kevin [at] RightWall.com Kevin H Blenkinsopp
kielmann [at] cs.vu.nl Thilo Kielmann
klein [at] newmonics.com Andrew Klein
KousenKA [at] utrc.utc.com Kenneth A. Kousen
kpascoe [at] ford.com Kathy Pascoe
kwong [at] cs.ubc.ca Ken Wong
larrybr [at] seanet.com Larry Brasfield
lee.s.fields [at] usa.dupont.com Lee S. Fields
lindstrom [at] oma.com Lowell Lindstrom
Link [at] decrc.abb.de Johannes Link
list-votes [at] dream.kn-bremen.de Martin Schr"oder
llgerholz [at] mmm.com Laurie Gerholz
MacDonaldRJ [at] bv.com Richard
macgyver [at] dcc.ufmg.br Cassio Pennachin
maeder [at] glue.ch Thomas Maeder
mahesh [at] paragon-software.com B.G. Mahesh
mal [at] bewoner.dma.be Lieven Marchand
malay [at] miel.mot.com Malay Vaishanv
mamcdow [at] ia.net Mark A. McDowell
manfred.schneider [at] rhein-neckar.de Manfred Schneider
marco_dallaGasperina [at] mentorg.com Marco Dalla Gasperina
mark [at] hsi.com Mark Sicignano
mark.fussell [at] chimu.com Mark Fussell
Mark.Wright [at] NBNZ.CO.NZ Mark Wright
Matt.Terski [at] mchugh.com Matthew A. Terski
Matthew.Helliwell [at] dresdnerkb.com Matt Helliwell
matts [at] shore.net Matt Sullivan
mayp [at] tibco.com Patrick May
mcbreenp [at] cadvision.com Pete McBreen
mckewan [at] tmqaustin.com Andrew McKewan
mdick [at] insect.sd.monash.edu.au Martin Dick
mfl [at] sams.co.uk Martin Flower
mgc [at] cs.rmit.edu.au Michael Chamberlain
Michael.McMahon.mmcmahon [at] nt.com Michael McMahon
Michel.Clamagirand [at] alcatel.fr Michel Clamagirand
michi [at] dstc.edu.au Michi Henning
Mike.Parmley [at] postoffice.co.uk Mike Parmley
millette [at] bigfoot.com Robin Y. Millette
mkc [at] sky.net Mike Coleman
mlievaart [at] orion.nl Martijn Lievaart
mmeijeri [at] wi.leidenuniv.nl Martijn Meijering
mmquinn1 [at] mmm.com Michael M. Quinn
mooring [at] antares.Tymnet.COM Ed Mooring
mshoemaker [at] insight-tech.com Michael Shoemaker
mslamm [at] mscc.huji.ac.il Ehud Lamm
msundararajan [at] ibs-ltd.co.uk Mukundan Sundararajan
murphyjr [at] mags.net James R. Murphy
nab [at] acm.org Neville Black
naddy [at] mips.rhein-neckar.de Christian Weisgerber
nate [at] mcnamara.net Nate McNamara
newkirk [at] oma.com James Newkirk
Nick.Mein [at] trimble.co.nz Nick Mein
NickKetter [at] mindspring.com Nicholas J Ketter
nidoyle [at] nortel.ca Nicholas Doyle
np [at] stardivision.de Nikolai Pretzell
objetos [at] satlink.com Miguel J. Pinkas
olczyk [at] interaccess.com Thaddeus L. Olczyk
oliva [at] dcc.unicamp.br Alexandre Oliva
oliverr [at] pop.erols.com Robert G. Oliver
ottinger [at] oma.com Tim Ottinger
P.Roberts [at] perth.wgc.com.au Paul Roberts
pachling [at] kapsch.net Walter Pachlinger
palecoin [at] my-dejanews.com Pascal LECOINTE
patrickl [at] servio.gemstone.com Patrick D. Logan
pats [at] acm.org Patricia Shanahan
paul.grealish [at] uk.geopak-tms.com Paul Grealish
Paul.Webster.paulweb [at] nt.com Paul Webster
pch [at] verdi.iisd.sra.com Peter C. Halverson
per.angstrom [at] mind.nu Per �ngstr�m
peter [at] weblogic.com Peter Seibel
peter.lindgren [at] emw.ericsson.se Peter Lindgren
pezzini [at] ibm.net Igor Pezzini
pgoodwin [at] my-dejanews.com Phil Goodwin
phil [at] panix.com Phil Gustafson
phil [at] paule.demon.co.uk Philip William Britton
philip [at] preston20.freeserve.co.uk Philip Preston
plogston [at] yahoo.com Paul Logston
polemic [at] iinet.net.au Richard Puchmayer
poleur [at] crpcu.lu Michel Poleur
porter.clark [at] msfc.nasa.gov J. Porter Clark
potargen [at] imec.be Freddy Potargent
prudrakshala [at] statestreet.com Purush Rudrakshala
pschow [at] advtech.uswest.com Peter Schow
psnorby [at] cacd.rockwell.com P.S. Norby
qranian [at] lmera.ericsson.se Niklas Storm
Ralf.Comtesse [at] microtool.de Ralf
rapp [at] lmr.com Larry Rappaport
rbinder [at] rbsc.com Robert V. Binder
reissing [at] informatik.uni-stuttgart.de Ralf Reissing
rfkat [at] ibm.net Rolf F. Katzenberger
rgarcia4 [at] darwin.helios.nd.edu Ronald Garcia
rich [at] dsp.sps.mot.com Richard Bartlett
rick [at] bcm.tmc.edu Richard Miller
ricksand [at] mediaone.net Rick Sanderson
riddle [at] Iname.com Steve Riddle
ritzmann [at] trshp.ntc.nokia.com Fabian Ritzmann
rkirti [at] ix.netcom.com Rituraj Kirti
rmartin [at] oma.com Robert C. Martin
Robert.Lukassen [at] ehv.ce.philips.com Robert J. Lukassen
roland [at] inherit.se Roland Hedayat</BLOCKQUOTE>
rracine [at] draper.com Roger Racine
rstamerjohn [at] QGRAPH.COM Ralph Stamerjohn
rufinus [at] mbe.ece.wisc.edu J Rufinus
russ_freeman [at] hotmail.com Russ Freeman
rvaitk [at] soften.ktu.lt Raimundas Vaitkevicius
s.sudik [at] larc.nasa.gov Steven Sudik
safa [at] icrl.mew.co.jp Laurent SAFA
salter [at] chrontech.com Steven Salter
Sandy.Grosvenor [at] gsfc.nasa.gov Sandy Grosvenor
sbo [at] psy.med.uni-muenchen.de Boris Schaefer
schlegel [at] informatik.uni-rostock.de J=FCrgen Schlegelmilch
schmidt [at] cs.wustl.edu Douglas C. Schmidt
schuerig [at] acm.org Michael Schuerig
seriakov [at] aha.ru George Seriakov
sferris [at] tiny.net Scott M. Ferris
sgb [at] praxis-cs.co.uk Stephen Bull
shrum [at] hpnut.fc.hp.com Ken Shrum
simon [at] icpdd.neca.nec.com.au Simon A. Crase
simon.guest [at] roke.co.uk Simon Guest
simonwillcocks [at] enterprise.net Simon Willcocks
sintzoff [at] art.alcatel.fr Andr=E9 Sintzoff
source [at] netcom.com David Harmon
squeegee [at] concentric.net Stephen C. Gilardi
srini_n1 [at] verifone.com Srinivasan N.
srs [at] vuse.vanderbilt.edu Stephen R. Schach
steve.banks [at] marketdatasys.com Steve Banks
Susan.Allen [at] PSS.Boeing.com Susan A. Allen
sven [at] sass.de Sven Sass
swelham [at] mlswa.uk.lucent.com Stuart Welham
tannhauser [at] crf.canon.fr Falk Tannh=E4user
tc [at] gauss.muc.de Matthias Hoelzl
thomas.land [at] rhein-main.net Thomas Land
tmoore [at] celwave.com Thomas Moore
tony.payton [at] gecm.com Tony Payton
trajon [at] fred.net Jon Poletti
travis [at] SEDSystems.ca Shane Travis
treid [at] primenet.com Tom Reid
tseaver [at] palladion.com Tres Seaver
va [at] org.chemie.uni-frankfurt.de Volker Apelt
vijay [at] CellNet.com Vijay Ramachandran
vote-n-run [at] huug.demon.nl huug
westphal [at] acm.org Frank Westphal
wilba [at] bigfoot.com Alan Williams
winkler [at] balancetechnology.com Peter K. Winkler
wkdugan [at] ix.netcom.com Bill Dugan
wolf.siberski [at] rwg.de Wolf Siberski
wolfgang.poechgraber [at] sea.ericsson.se Wolfgang Poechgraber
xanthian [at] well.com Kent Paul Dolan
yardley [at] interlog.com Graham N. Yardley
yCothouit [at] teaser.fr Domenikos Theotokopoulos
yonat [at] email.com Ron Yonat
yonat [at] usa.net Yonat Sharon
zach [at] instantplanet.com Zach Baker
Voted No
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
aj [at] arthur.rhein-neckar.de Andreas Jaeger
AlanM [at] hpdi.demon.co.uk Alan Macro
brownbear [at] earthdome.com Ira Brown
capitaljo [at] fexnet.com Jodie Ballast
Dale.A.Force [at] lerc.nasa.gov Dale Force
dialysis [at] starplace.com Guy Marciano
dringhof [at] linktrader.com Doc Ringhoff
ell [at] access.digex.net Elliott Coates
erigbadj [at] postmaster.co.uk Eric Badger
fayet [at] nancy.inra.fr Guy FAYET
ferret [at] enteract.com Karl Meyer
Hein.Roehrig [at] cwi.nl Hein Roehrig
hougen [at] cs.umn.edu Dean Hougen
kimdv [at] best.com Kim DeVaughn
knemeyer [at] ix.netcom.com Manfred Knemeyer
laverno [at] pacbell.net La Vern R. Ogden
madhusudhan.r.doddabele [at] lmco.com madhu
olav [at] viking.mv.com Olav Nieuwejaar
phil [at] pfsystems.com Phil Stenson
RBaker6223 [at] aol.com Ray Baker
sean.duffy [at] goldengate.net Sean Duffy
stainles [at] bga.com Dwight Brown
territickle [at] heartthrob.com Terri DeSistoh
wakelyn [at] pinn.net N. T. Wakelyn
Abstained
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
AshleyB [at] halcyon.com Ashley Yakeley
chris [at] kzim.com Christopher Robin Zimmerman
gjohnson [at] dream.season.com Gary Johnson
murray-paul [at] usa.net Paul Murray
rich [at] vax2.concordia.ca Rich Lafferty
prev parent reply other threads:[~1998-11-19 0:00 UTC|newest]
Thread overview: 12+ messages / expand[flat|nested] mbox.gz Atom feed top
1998-08-27 0:00 RFD: comp.object.moderated moderated Tim Ottinger
[not found] ` <H5oH1.634$495.190709860@newsreader.digex.net>
[not found] ` <35ee6ccb.0@news2.ibm.net>
1998-09-06 0:00 ` Ell
1998-09-07 0:00 ` Rolf F. Katzenberger
1998-09-07 0:00 ` Charles Hixson
1998-09-08 0:00 ` Tim Ottinger
1998-09-17 0:00 ` Tim Ottinger
1998-09-07 0:00 ` Robert Martin
1998-09-08 0:00 ` Rolf F. Katzenberger
1998-10-28 0:00 ` CFV: " David Bostwick
1998-11-11 0:00 ` 2nd " David Bostwick
1998-11-14 0:00 ` Patrick Doyle
1998-11-19 0:00 ` David Bostwick [this message]
replies disabled
This is a public inbox, see mirroring instructions
for how to clone and mirror all data and code used for this inbox