Re: address/access/pointer confusion

[aschwarz@acm.org (skidmarks)]

> I think that not the same definition??
> Can anybody tell me the exact difference between pointer in C++ and
> access/address types in Ada???

(From dialogs on comp.lang.ada):

A C/C++ pointer is an address to an object. The object contains no
compiler provided information concerning it's semantics (and the
application can reinterpret the semantics freely using a cast).

An Ada Access Type is a pointer to an Ada representation of an object.
This representation can be an object, a la C/C++, or a pointer to a
dope vector providing semantic content of the object (and perhaps
other things - I'm not an Ada afficionado). The compiler vendor is
free to choose the interpretation and meaning of an Access Type
subject to the LRM.

Ad Ada Address is a pointer in the same sense as a C/C++ pointer, with
similar operations and interpretation. The proviso is that the Address
can (presumably) point to a dope vector (I need clarification on this)
but may also point to a raw object.

As an example:
    C/C++:     int a[20];
               int *p  = a;
               int *p1 = &a[0];

               // p == p1 == &a[0] the address of the first item in
the
                                   array a (by definition &a == &a(0))

    Ada:       type Arg        is array( 0 .. 19 O of Integer;
               type Arg_Access is access all Arg;
               a  : aliased Arg;
               p  : Arg_Access     := a'Access;
               p1 : System.Address := a(0)'Address;

               -- p /= p1 in general
               -- One representation of 'a' could be:
               -- a  => <<size of a><pointer to space for a>> --> a(0)
               -- p  => points to the 'a' dope vector (above)
               -- p1 => points to the first element of a, a(0)
               -- 
               -- In this case, p1 is equivalent to the C/C++ p, p1,
               --               p  has no C/C++ equivalency

I think I've got it correct. No doubt someone more knowledgeable will
fill in the edges if there are any errors.

art